Posts
As they say, "If you cant beat them then join them".. Hindus are also very active in pointing out the "so called" mistakes..
Here is something I found on the web.. Its supposed to mean that Hinduism and all its forms are wrong.. Its just an example that Allah knows best and we humans are just fools.. For those hindus who deny Islam based on those "So Called" errors, I would like that you deny Hinduis, if you find all these things down here to be true.. Even One of Them.. My challenge..
Error
In Mahabharata, particularly in the Bhagavad Gita, and other Hindu scriptures, we find that Krishna is depicted having only two hands. But, at one place in the Gita, we see a mistake mentioning four hands!
Gita 11:46 “…Appear with that very form with four hands!”
Error
Actually, Sanjaya is watching all the happenings including the show of Viswa Roopa that is shown to Arjuna. And, previously, as it is reported in the Maha Bharata, some of the enemies of Arjuna have seen this form before many others. But, strangely enough to read, it is mentioned as :
Gita 11:47 “ Out of grace, O Arjuna, this supreme, radiant, cosmic, infinite, primeval form – which (form) of mine has not been seen before by anyone other than you, has been shown to you by me through the power of my own yoga. ”
“Arjuna, by my favour, you have seen this loftiest form by my yoga revealed! … that none except yourself has ever seen”
Error
As we already know, Sanjaya is narrating the whole process to the emperor Dhritarashtra, the father of Arjuna’s enemies. Normally, if ‘A’ is speaking to ‘B’ and A wants to say that B’s brother is coming, he would say, “Mr. B! your brother is coming.” Or, “B! your brother is coming.” But, he would not say, “B’s brother is coming.”
Let us see the same thing in the Gita. It is mentioned in Gita 1:19-20, “the blowing of these different couch shells became uproarious. Vibrating both in the sky and in the earth, it shattered the hearts of the sons of Dhritarashtra… O King, after looking at the sons of Dhritarashtra drawn in military array, Arjuna then spoke to Krishna these words.”
As we all know today that the sun, moon and stars are all inanimate objects and cannot have wife and children like the human beings. But, in the olden days, the Hindu brothers did not know this fact and they used to hold the belief that these are all gods only. Further, they used to believe that they had marital relationship and parental relationship with human beings. Anyway, we are going to see it in detail under the heading, “Hindu Gods”. Here, we are going to have a look at the sample, which proves beyond doubt that even the Bhagavad Gita is not immune from this belief!
It is mentioned in Gita 4:1, “I have given this infinite knowledge to Sun, he taught it to his son Manu (one of the ancestors of the mankind) and he taught it to his son Ikshwaka (one of famous saints)”
It is surprising to see that the Gita attributes sonship of a human to a star that is ‘the sun’.
Some scholars of Hinduism hold that the Gita doesn’t say that Manu was a son of the sun. But, they all admit that the Gita mentions the sun having taught a particular knowledge to Manu. Even this is hard to defend against scientific criticism.
**************
Source:
http://www.islam4all.com/introduction_to_hinduism_page_7.htm
A reminder again! Please double check the verses.. If you find them true.. Then I win..
16 comment(s):
Mr who ever you are,
Do you want me to quote piles of errors in Quran and hadith? Do you want me to specify in details about the character of your prophet Mohammed including all his marriages? Do you want me to quote about his murderous RAIDS on innocent and unarmed civilians and giving it a name as WAR?
Tell me honey.....do you want everything?
bastards.......you have the god damned right to write any anti-hindu articles and when someone writes on anti-muslim, it goes for approval. This is what islam religion is? Intolerant and most violent? Apes and still becoming apes of brainless Arabs.
Ah.. Please do quote! If you just dont copy paste everything thats on the net! Try to find the authentic sources of Islam.. And see if the error is there!! Please do!
Actually I dont have the right! You are correct.. But my friend, if you go through my blog, you will find a hindu guy sumwhere arguing no true religion will have errors etc.. He argued Hinduism was perfect.. and I am proving his argument wrong.. and to tell you the truth I copy pasted it from sumwhere on the internet (and thus i am not sure if they exist.. y dun u check ur vedas and see if they correct or not.. and do temme if u do!! )
Thankksss... and Islam is tolerant, and Islam is universal.. Not just the Arabs.. (u made me smile when u said that..)
:) hopin u reply soon!
i wonder why some people fail to coolly reply to your comments, Qazi.
but i like the response, at least it goes inside their heads for a second.
Thank You O Anonymous Person,
I would really appreciate if you put in your own comments/ replies to the billions of questions that are put. Answering them isnt just my responsibility is it?
OPEN UR MIND PAL
Unfortunately Islam and christanity both are fighting to place their rules in the world and demise others as if there idea are the correct and the rest of the world is wrong ,this is what is called packaged religion,SUBSCRIBE TO OUR PACKAGE AND YOU WILL BE FREE FROM ALL UR PAINS
where as in hinduism you are open to ideas of other religion(what u call as),ppl who call them hindu go to mazar and to churches because they are open to new ideas and philosophy
OPEN UR MIND PAL
Unfortunately Islam and christanity both are fighting to place their rules in the world and demise others as if there idea are the correct and the rest of the world is wrong ,this is what is called packaged religion,SUBSCRIBE TO OUR PACKAGE AND YOU WILL BE FREE FROM ALL UR PAINS
where as in hinduism you are open to ideas of other religion(what u call as),ppl who call them hindu go to mazar and to churches because they are open to new ideas and philosophy
Secondly the word hinduism is given by the packaged religions like islam and the christianity because they cannot believe some one not believing in any religion rather believing in truth and way of life(dharma)so they gave a name
packaged religions convert ppl by baptizing to christianity or embracing islam,no such ideas exist in hindus,just dont search for materials on errors in hinduism rather try to delve in to books for truth,because every analysis either praises or criticizes ,DEPENDING ON THEIR BELEIF AND FAITH
@A
I managed to sum up a few points. Correct me if i misunderstood your comment..
1. as if their idea is correct and the rest of the world is wrong.
2. Subscribe and be free from all ur pains..
3. Hinduism : Open to ideas of other religions.
4. believing in truth and way of life..
5. every analysis either praises or criticizes..
Ok! Those were the questions.. Here, I present the solution manual :)
Ans1: Well, what makes you think your ideas are correct.. A Hindu worshippes so many gods thats its hard to imagine. Here is something I read from a very common science book :
"The early man used to worship things: whatever harmed them or whatever fascinated them. In some parts of the world, people started worshipping the moon as the god of night while in other places it was said to be the god of peace. Elsewhere cattle and other animals were worshipped. In Early Chinese civilisations, people worshipped the ancestors and believed them to be the cause of misfortune as well as prosperity"
If you read this extract, and if you think its rubbish.. Well think again.. Coz thats how I look at Hinduism..
Ans2: Accepting Islam doesnt mean end to pains.. It just takes out of the eternal stay in Hell. Then you have to follow Islam, like no drinking alcohol, no extra-maritial affairs or adultery/ no sodomy etc.. A Muslim will be punished for all the mistakes he has commited, (and even a lie is a 'gunaah'). And that you will be raised up again from the dead..
3. Hinduism is open to other ideas.. Well I should believe only good ideas right? Let me give u an example.. In a country (I wont say which) the consumption of liquor was not allowed.. But when the people became angry.. They jsut changed the law. They didnt see thw wrong thing.. All they saw was would they be happy and cheerful.. Thats the worst example I can give.. I want to ask you.. Is Hinduism open to such ideas as well?
Ans4: Do you really think that the truth will be so many gods (who surprisingly dont even fight considering the level of anger which some of them have). I expect you to know what "OM" means in Hinduism.. It means 1 God.. Awaiting ur reply..
Ans5: Every analysis either praises or criticizes... :) NO BIG DEAL... :)
Peace:
Qazi Mamoon
sorry for replying late
Unfortunately u ppl dont understand what is hinduism,that is why u criticize for having 1000 gods,actually hindus are group of community who believe in few common ideas,it is for one choice to worship whatever way they want to be
there is no hardcore rule set as islam as{way of living which ppl call},follow whatever u wish to is the idealogy of hinduism .........rather dharma {i shud refrain from the word hinduism given to us by the west}but respect whatever the others do ie dont desecrate the others beleif
lets answer wht u answer-
ans 1- early man used to worship cattle weapons etc,true there is no mentioning of cattle of weapon worship in vedas ,ppl got them through ignorance,but that doesnt count as dharma{does it}
what makes me think my ideas are correct , everybody islam christainity or anything else believes that there ideas are correct,the fact that u ppl beleive that ur truth is correct and others are wrong ,this lead to so many crusades and wars in the middle east,hindus believe there is a truth rather than the truth,ie ur are right and i am right,dont disrespect others,if u r good person u will lead to good outcome whatever u believe,so do i if i do good
the philosophy is hard to understand even the new generation hindus are as fundamenalist as islam or christainity is.
ans2-sorry christianity beleives in healing of pain and everything but the fact is that all juda-abhram philosophy including islam beleives in heaven and hell,so wht wud happen if u go to heaven will u enjoy for ever..good food,good climate...??
look apart from god everything is illusion,it is him who created u and me,the ultimate goal shud be achive god instead of lure of heaven
u shud no that even heaven and hell is created by god{illusion}so u r living in the world of illusion ,where nothing is true accept god,life is a test of soul to reach god and not to heaven
u wud find it diff to beleive these but the fact is lure of going to heaven or getting rid of hell is not for which a man shud work,instead it shud do good for sake of nothing{nishkaam karma}
ans3-lets not discuss politics,india is not a hindu state and even if it wud have been u cant guarantee wht ppl do
quite a no of ppl drink in dubai,so is it islam....
ans4-i beleive god is one or is it?,om is not god it is considered as sacred sound which will relate to god ,the point is that the day u and everybody understand that every path is correct ,there will be no argument that islam is great or hinduism is great,
the fact is that god is undefinable ,who can be whtever it wants to be,islam believes god is undefinable and god is one,i was hearing zakir naik lecture a few days back he was saying"if u imagine this is god ........that not allah,if u imagine that is god........thats not god.......u cant imagine god"
the fact is that god is beyond ur imagination he can become anything,pious or unpious{hard to believe how god can become unpious like dirt??}
he can be one,he can be many,he can be anywhere and can be anything
which lead to the belief of hindus that god is one,god is many ,god is nirguna{undefinable},god is saguna{definable like worshipping of idols}
ans5-every analysis either praises or criticizes..no big deal
we are back to square one,i wud say
OPEN UR MIND PAL
the day u believe {even for a bit}that ur religion is not supreme,u will understand that other beief are as good as urs,if not btr,
the fact is that u know{u think so i mean} that islam is supreme,closes ur mind however hard u analyse other religions,however hard u try to get goods from other belief u wud never reach the exteme truth of mankind,{coz u believe that only quran is true so if anything that is in quran too than that is true else......}
religion are made for btrment of man bt ppl { islam and christainity ,unfortunately the new breed fo hindus too}fight to prove u r right and the other is wrong
I am sorry!! Been a lot busy... But inshaAllah will reply to your lon long comments.. :)
Post a Comment